Arman Shaban Trading Telegram Channel Review – Low Trust Signals

When evaluating a forex signals Telegram channel, traders must look for transparency, consistency, and verifiable performance. Unfortunately, Arman Shaban Trading falls short in a number of areas, making it a dangerous choice for both new and experienced traders. Below, we break down the primary issues in greater detail in our new review.

Key Details of Arman Shaban Trading Channel

Telegram Channel Link - https://t.me/PriceAction_ICT

Feature	Details
Launch Date	April 4, 2021
Subscribers	11,865 (medium-sized)
Posts Per Day	~8 (highly active)
Average Views/Post	~1,300 (likely real engagement)
Free Signals Provided	Yes, but only ~1 per day
Signal Quality	Very poor – no clear entry, SL, or TP; only vague forecasts
Winning Rate (Backtested)	Only 15% (based on 7 months of data)
Paid Services	VIP signals & gold channel access (no subscription bot)
Suspicious Practices	Misleading analysis, no clear signals, constant self-promotion requests

1. Lack of Clear & Actionable Trading Signals

A decent forex signals Telegram channel should provide:

✔ Precise entry points (not sloppy zones)

✔ Clear stop-loss (SL) and take-profit (TP) levels

✔ Quality charts with shown directions (arrows, trend lines, etc.)

Arman Shaban's signals fall short on all these aspects:

• No entry points – General "zones" only that leave traders to figure things out themselves.

  
  

• No stop-loss guidance – A huge red flag, as proper risk management is paramount.

  
  

• No take-profit levels – Rarely, the channel provides occasional 3-5 TPs, which is not possible.

  
  

• Charts in file format (not images) – An unnecessary nightmare for users.

  
  

This formlessness makes the traders incapable of taking or backtesting the signals accordingly, rendering them practically useless.

2. Far Too Low Win Rate (Just 15%)

We have backtested all our free signals over 7 months and found:

• Only 15% were winners – Appalling performance.

  
  

• Many "wins" were inflated – The author sometimes refers to minor price movements (even 1 pip) as successful trades.

  
  

• No verified track record – Unlike reputable signal sources, this channel does not provide open trade history.

  
  

• For comparison purposes, most reputable signal services have at least a 50-60% win rate with apparent risk-reward ratios. A 15% success rate is essentially worse than random guessing.

3. Misleading Analysis & Erratic Signals

Another matter of concern is blended and often opposing trading concepts:

• "Sell and buy" advice in the same report – A common technique in low-grade channels to later report a "win" regardless of the market's direction.

• Mostly daily charts and not intraday configurations – While professing to be offering day trade signals, most are given on longer timeframes and are therefore meaningless to short-term traders.

  
  

• No updates on prior clues – Signs left abandoned without developments, making members wonder.

• Lack of coherence prevents deciphering a system for trading out of this channel.

4. Too Much Self-Promotion & Fee-Charged Service Bragging

While there are Telegram channels offering paid-for VIP signs, Arman Shaban Trading stands out through its way-too-honest self-promoting activities:

• Many postings each day by the VIP group reposted – Evidently trying to entice freebies to paid-up members.

• Constantly asking for Trading View comments – The author asks followers to comment on his charts 3-4 times a day, perhaps to artificially generate his social proof.

• No bot VIP subscription – Manually managed paid access is unsettling when it comes to accountability.

Such behavior suggests the channel cares more about promotion than actual trading worth.

5. Questionable Risk Management & False Profit Claims

A trading channel that presents itself as professional should emphasize:

✔ Correct risk-reward ratios (e.g., 1:2 or 1:3)

✔ Logical stop-loss rules for safeguarding capital

✔ Sensible take-profit levels

Rather than this, this channel:

• Does not mention stop-loss in most cases, leaving traders with unlimited risk.

• Uses 3-5 take-profit points – A manipulative strategy to win half of the battles even if the trade fails.

• Marking small price movements as "successful signals" – Misleading followers into thinking the predictions are accurate.

  
  
  
  

1/10 TRUST SCORE

Final Verdict & Review: Stay Away From This Channel

Based on diligent evaluation, we remark that Arman Shaban Trading is a low-trust Telegram channel with:

❌ Poor quality signals (15% winning percentage)

❌ No levels for entry, SL, or TP

❌ Misleading analysis & inconsistent forecasts

❌ Over-relied self-praising & remunerated service propaganda

Should you be looking for reliable forex signals, we recommend choosing a confirmed Telegram channel that features:

✔ Open transparency record

✔ Clarity regarding risk management directives

✔ Routine, good quality analysis